I venture to say I like my BedTred more than the Bedrug. Both were padded, but the BedTred looks just like a spray in, and is a little easier to keep clean (I use it like a truck) lol. Truckmods.com gave me great deals on both.
I like the Bedrug in my red truck. I don't have a cover on it but it parks inside and I don't use it for dirty stuff so I can't really speak on durability. It looks a hell of a lot better than the 20 year old used bed floor though.
I have one in my truck (Austin's old one) and it is fine. I don't really care about it one way or the other because it is always under the cover. Austin's Bedtred was extremely nice and what I would do if i had to do it over again.
Got my bedrug for $50 off CL. Couldn't beat that. I like it. Nothing ever slides around. And Everyone else is about amazed that there's carpet stuff in my bed lol